The Definition of Durability in Engineering: Expectations Vs. Reality

Handing over project specifications requires everyone in the supply and production chain to be on the same page. Down to the word, even.

“Durability,” for example, can have many definitions and interpretations.

While the OEM engineer might have a specific understanding in mind, the purchasing agent or others in supply chain management could have alternative perspectives. Meanwhile, the contract manufacturer is throwing its hands up when trying to read your spec sheet. You might end up sending the wrong message (literally) to your roll forming manufacturer, resulting in a component that doesn’t prioritize the attributes your project needs most.

While the standards of product development and manufacturing are generally well understood, you may consider durability to mean something different than your roll former does. We count five basic definitions of durability in engineering. Use them well so you can better communicate product needs to your manufacturing partner!

5 Definitions of Durability in Engineering for Roll Forming

In the roll forming process, there are five ways to define durability in engineering. To get the component you want, make sure to understand each:

1. Strength
2. Hardness
3. Corrosion resistance
4. Wear resistance
5. Impact toughness

The definition of “durability” in manufacturing can range anywhere from a lawn mower part that lasts for 400 hours to a car part that withstands 200,000 miles of abuse. In roll forming, understanding durability can get you a cost-effective part that endures the stress of your specific application. 

1. Strength

Strength could mean a roll formed part is strong enough to be a little flexible so it can withstand consistent loads. But it can also mean the product is so stiff it doesn’t bounce back at all.

When an OEM asks a roll forming partner, “What is the strongest metal?” for its intended application, this underlying understanding should be communicated. The metal’s properties can then be assessed and matched up against the complexity of the bending you want. 

If the end product is a bike, the durability of steel is perfect for the frame, but only certain mix of steel that's flexible enough to absorb shock. A steel grade that’s too rigid would provide a rough ride, and maybe even crack if the cyclist hits a bump. Brittleness beware!

2. Hardness

In terms of durability, the definition of hardness is the ability of a roll forming material to resist ...

• Surface indentation
• Abrasion
• Erosion 

… without becoming brittle.

If you’re designing metal components for a train, durability usually refers to surface hardness. Here the metal is case hardened, heat treated, and quenched to make the outside super-hard. The inside remains softer.

Now consider padlocks. These are made hard enough that they cannot be cut by thieves, but they also can’t be overly brittle. Here the roll former should recommend the most durable metal your application can use without cracking. 

3. Corrosion Resistance

If your roll formed steel shapes will be exposed to weather or salt-heavy environments, “durability” talk should focus on rust and corrosion resistance.

In these cases, carbon steels -- whether they’re hot or cold rolled -- won’t be effective. Your components will begin to rust very quickly, although there are some alloying elements that can improve the corrosion resistance of carbon steel.

Corrosion resistance is also important for load-bearing parts at the point of stress. Depending on the shape, the areas that experience the most stress may be especially vulnerable to oxidation and corrosion. This is because the microstructure of the steel is being pulled apart.

4. Wear Resistance

If a part is brushing up against other parts, you can bet there will be friction. Of course, friction creates heat, but it also may cause particles of your component to fritter away.

In these applications, lubrication is a must so heat doesn’t build up to the point of component failure. That’s why a car engine uses oil. If it wasn’t there, the heat would be so intense that the engine block would burn up.

Keep in mind the components must also have high hardness to resist constant wear.

5. Impact Toughness

Toughness refers to the capacity of a material to absorb mechanical energy without permanently changing.

Toughness often decreases as hardness increases. Items like a cymbal or hotel corridor mouldings are a compromise of toughness and hardness, so they can withstand impact without sustaining surface abrasions or dents.

How to Design a Durable Roll Formed Product

How you deal with durability will usually depend on what is being designed.

The durability of building materials is becoming more important to architects and designers as sustainable construction is emphasized more and more. Copper’s durability is applauded for its ability to be both flexible and long-lasting, making it great for, say, door components. In a car chassis, though, the designer wants door crossmembers that maintain their shape during an accident, but not so much that the impact force spreads to the whole vehicle.

As you can see, “durability” is all over the place. Make sure your expectations of what durability means meet the reality of what you and your roll forming partner design. Here's a free e-book to get you started in the right direction:

Editor's note: This article was originally published in November 2019 and was recently updated.