As with all manufacturing processes, the way you design your component impacts your overall costs, lead times, and quality consistency. Follow these roll forming design tips to avoid the common pitfalls of custom tooling and forming.
Some components require difficult or non-standard manufacturing work, so you may not be able to follow all of these rules. However, by removing as many unnecessary hurdles as possible, you can make your part more affordable while maintaining design integrity.
Avoid These 8 Roll Forming Design Oops-es
Roll form design can go off the tracks quickly if you make one or more of these eight mistakes:
- 90° sidewalls
- Small bend radii
- Extremely short legs
- Wide, sweeping bend radii
- Blind corners
- Narrow openings
- Deep, narrow sections
- Wide shapes & forming work on one edge
1. 90° Sidewalls
The Problem: These require additional roll passes, which increase roll wear and contribute to tooling scuff marks along the vertical sidewalls.
The Fix: Open your design enough to allow your pieces to nest into each other. This will also increase stacking and shipping efficiency.
2. Small Bend Radii
The Problem: Tight corners cause cracking in heavy-gauge roll forming materials due to stresses generated in the outer fibers of the bend. They also increase tool wear and breakage, and require a mill with greater horsepower (all of which affect your costs).
The Fix: Allow for a minimum radius of 1.5 to 2x the material thickness for best results.
3. Extremely Short Legs
The Problem: Short legs can be impossible to form in heavier gauge materials.
The Fix: Allow for at least 3x the material gauge as a minimum “flat.” Longer legs provide enough leverage to bend heavier materials.
4. Wide, Sweeping Bend Radii
The Fix: Design for flat sections with discrete bends. This will also reduce roll forming tool design costs and initial setup scrap.
5. Blind Corners
The Problem: Also called “air bends,” blind corners occur when the roll forming dies cannot contact both the inside and the outside of a formed corner. These bends become less accurate and are more difficult to control.
The Fix: Design your component to avoid this situation completely -- make sure the part will be in contact with inside and outside rollers at all times.
6. Narrow Openings
The Problem: Narrow openings (in relation to the overall size of shape) make designing cutoff tooling extremely difficult and costly. They also result in frequent cutoff die breakage.
The Fix: When designing your part, allow for more than half of section width for your opening.
7. Deep, Narrow Sections
The Problem: These designs require large-diameter forming dies, which increases the cost of tooling, wear, and scuff marks on the part.
The Fix: Make the flat section wider or open the sidewalls at an angle. If you absolutely require a deep, narrow channel, ask us about our MeshTrim offerings.
8. Wide Shapes + Forming Work on One Edge
The Problem: These parts are unbalanced and difficult to keep from twisting.
The Fix: Add a small leg or offset on the flat edge for greater strength and balance.
What else can make your design better for roll forming?
A great part design also includes tolerances that are tight enough to meet the expected quality range and part function, but broad enough to allow the manufacturer some wiggle room. As with all part designs, tighter tolerances usually lead to higher costs.
While the above points provide guidelines on what to avoid, all of these features CAN be overcome through:
- Smart roll forming tool design
- Appropriate metal specification control
- The right roll forming equipment
However, as we stated previously, if all of these conditions can be avoided, decreased cost will be your reward.
If you have any further questions about designing your component for roll forming, please contact us.
(Editor's note: This article was originally published in January 2016 and was recently updated.)
Tooling costs in manufacturing are already a sore spot for many purchasers, but some think roll forming tooling is cost-prohibitive altogether. Sadly, the up-front price tag blinds them to literal down-the-line savings.
That’s right -- if your project fits, a roll former can actually optimize[...]
Quick: Which charges higher prices for metal fabrication -- a company that has in-house roll forming tooling design capabilities or one that outsources it?
There will always be designers who want control of every single detail, down to the last thread, sliver, or scrap. That philosophy can apply to choosing decorative metal trim. To each their own, we say.